Album Elimination Game! Dream Theater vs. Symphony X (VOTE NOW)

Black Sabbath-6
Megadeth-5

Black Sabbath-7
Megadeth-6

Weird mix, I think some parameters need to be set in place.

Nazgul wrote:

Black Sabbath-7
Megadeth-6

Weird mix, I think some parameters need to be set in place.

I agree, I felt the same way about Dio and Metal Church

metalinmyveins wrote:

This is the the thing I was little worried about. It was one thing to compare albums like that of Bonded By Blood and Master of Puppets, but these albums are nearly 20 years removed. Maybe their was a little more work regarding my tournament consisting of the year 1984, but those albums stacked up better against each other.

Comparing albums that are 20 years apart, is like asking if the Lakers team of the 80's could beat this years champion in the Celtics. It's too hard to pit albums of different generations against each other, just like it is with sports teams.

See this is what you get when people don't bother to show courtesy, If you remember the thread title I had, up to yesterday it was "'80's albums", now I (YES I) decided to choose 16 albums (read the first thread) for 8 battles, and the winners go through to the next round and so on until we get an over all winner from the initial 16 albums, but of course stupidy take control and fooks that up, so all you get is "my turn now". So to be truthful I'm not gonna fookin' bother any more, just do your own thing and leave me out of it.

and if any mods are wondering about this statement from me & why I'm annoyed, you guys knew there was a thread posted elsewhere that I had asked you's to update the battles if one album arrived at 10points before I returned.

After endless rounds of useless games, we finally get a good one, and just because people don`t bother to read what it`s about, the whole thing is of to hell...

Black Sabbath - 7
Megadeth - 7

Let's just finish this one, and get back on track with the next one. All is not lost!

I agree it suppose to be fun.

My bad. I was reminded of the Rainbow vs. Testament thread and this came up.

Black Sabbath - 8
Megadeth - 7

Sabbath - 9

Megadeth - 7

Okay, to end this.

Sabbath-10
Deth-7

Sorry about that.

Schbopo wrote:

Okay, to end this.

Sabbath-10
Deth-7

Sorry about that.

Don't feel bad.

In retrospect, I understand Lockey's annoyance but if I had just given the original post a cursory read, I might have misconstrued the original intent of this game too.

Lockey better come back or i'll have to do it lol.

Ha!

So which is the next one?

tohostudios wrote:

Schbopo wrote:

Okay, to end this.

Sabbath-10
Deth-7

Sorry about that.

Don't feel bad.

In retrospect, I understand Lockey's annoyance but if I had just given the original post a cursory read, I might have misconstrued the original intent of this game too.

You know I wasn't trying to be selfish here, but like Olafsto stated recently, we've had so many games that failed that I just attemped to see if this would work, that's why I picked the 16 albums to play so that we could see how it work out, I know people here like bands like Black Sabbath ect.... and them bands were not in the original 16, but if this went well I was hoping that we could then get submissions from the members here for different battles like, '70's albums, '90's albums, even battles for the different Genre's, so then all the members could recommend their albums and we'd take it from there.

ok I'll try this once more.


Round 3/8 (first to 10 Points)


Iron Maiden - The Number of the Beast



Vs

Megadeth - So Far, So Good, So What

Iron Maiden - 1
Megadeth - 0

Eddie eats Vic for dinner, film at 11.

I predict a landslide on this one

Maiden-2
Megadeth-0

Maiden-4
Megadeth-0

Maiden - 5
Megadeth - 0

maiden - 6
megadeth - 0

Iron Maiden-7
Megadeth-0

Man, I love both bands but it is hard to compete with Iron Maiden.