Album Elimination Game! Dream Theater vs. Symphony X (VOTE NOW)

Dio-3

Metal Church-3

Dio-3

Metal Church-4

Dio-4

Metal Church-4

Dio-5

Metal Church-4

Dio-6
Metal Church-4

Dio-6
Metal Church-5

Dio-7
Metal Church-5

Dio-8
Metal Church-5

Dio-9
Metal Church - 5

Dio-9
Metal Church - 6

Dio-10
Metal Church - 6

the godfather of heavy metal wins again

Dio - 10

Metal Church - 7

Okay, my turn to pick!



or...

Sabbath - 0

Megadeth - 1

SABBATH with who? if is with OZZY or which album I prefer.

Sabbath - 0

Megadeth - 2

Sabbath - 1
Megadeth - 2

Why we're comparing an album from 1970 with one 20 years later??? I haven't a clue. But in the grand scheme of things Sabbath is THE MOST INFLUENTIAL METAL BAND EVER...Megadeth put out a few good albums, but primarily they're not in the same ballpark...hell, they're not even in the same SPORT.

This is the the thing I was little worried about. It was one thing to compare albums like that of Bonded By Blood and Master of Puppets, but these albums are nearly 20 years removed. Maybe their was a little more work regarding my tournament consisting of the year 1984, but those albums stacked up better against each other.

Comparing albums that are 20 years apart, is like asking if the Lakers team of the 80's could beat this years champion in the Celtics. It's too hard to pit albums of different generations against each other, just like it is with sports teams.

I agree, albums of the same year (or at the very least a couple years apart) would make alot more sense.

Sabbath 2
Megadeth 2

Black Sabbath-3
Megadeth-2

Black Sabbath-4
Megadeth-2

Sabbath-4
Megadeth-3

Black Sabbath-4
Megadeth-4

Black Sabbath - 5
Megadeth - 4

Black Sabbath - 6
Megadeth - 4