Album Elimination Game! Dream Theater vs. Symphony X (VOTE NOW)

metalinmyveins wrote:

mc666 wrote:

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

I didn't edit it! Haha! Maybe someone is looking out for me!

If not we're going crazy.

Somebody vote!



I swear I'm not going crazy! Doesn't it said that I edited if I did!

- Robbie

yes it does. i think metalrob is confusing your post with that of metalinmyveins.

Incredible's post was definitely edited, whether he did it or not. He voted right after me, and I noticed that he had voted for both bands as well. I was going to say something, but MetalRob beat me to the punch. Someone's either not fessing up regarding their brain fart, or we have a sneaky editor on the boards.

The mystery continues.

THANX FOR CLEARING THAT UP.. Thought i was going nuts..

MetalRob331 wrote:

metalinmyveins wrote:

mc666 wrote:

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

I didn't edit it! Haha! Maybe someone is looking out for me!

If not we're going crazy.

Somebody vote!



I swear I'm not going crazy! Doesn't it said that I edited if I did!

- Robbie

yes it does. i think metalrob is confusing your post with that of metalinmyveins.

Incredible's post was definitely edited, whether he did it or not. He voted right after me, and I noticed that he had voted for both bands as well. I was going to say something, but MetalRob beat me to the punch. Someone's either not fessing up regarding their brain fart, or we have a sneaky editor on the boards.

The mystery continues.

THANX FOR CLEARING THAT UP.. Thought i was going nuts..

No, you're not going nuts, and I should've called out that error as well when it happened. I just didn't want to beat up on the guy, but it was most definitely changed.

All good. I'm just retarded! We all have our moments! I should proofread a bit more!

No worries, on with the game...

- Robbie

Iced Earth - 10

Nevermore - 6





Here is mine

Nightwish - Wishmaster
Sirenia - At Sixes And Sevens

MoonChild wrote:

Here is mine

Nightwish - Wishmaster
Sirenia - At Sixes And Sevens

Wow! Sucks for me. I am completely unfamiliar with these two albums.

Can't know 'em all I guess.

Nightwish - 1
Sirenia = 0

This would have been much tougher if the Sirenia was Nine Destinies.

Nightwish - 2
Sirenia - 0

ultmetal wrote:

MoonChild wrote:

Here is mine

Nightwish - Wishmaster
Sirenia - At Sixes And Sevens

Wow! Sucks for me. I am completely unfamiliar with these two albums.

Can't know 'em all I guess.

Nightwish - 3
Sirenia - 0

that Nightwish disc is one of my favorite metal cds of all time. I don't usually like too many lady singers in metal but you can't go wrong with Tarja she's amazing. I think you might dig this disc Scott. There is a whole lot of stuff on youtube from this album.

No he won't; he doesn't like Nightwish at all.

I agree with you on Wishmaster; easily one of my top 10 albums of all time.

tohostudios wrote:

No he won't; he doesn't like Nightwish at all.

I agree with you on Wishmaster; easily one of my top 10 albums of all time.

has he tried them out? He said he is not to familiar with them. IDK they are pretty awesome in my book...

He's heard Nightwish, apparently not Wishmaster though. I think the operatic vocals kill it for him.

tohostudios wrote:

He's heard Nightwish, apparently not Wishmaster though. I think the operatic vocals kill it for him.

Her vocals in Nightwish were what seperated them from the pack imo... Great cd though..

Never heard either of those bands.

Nightwish - 4
Sirenia - 0


TY

MoonChild wrote:

Nightwish - 3
Sirenia - 0

*EDIT* I was 3 this makes you 4?

MetalRob331 wrote:

tohostudios wrote:

No he won't; he doesn't like Nightwish at all.

I agree with you on Wishmaster; easily one of my top 10 albums of all time.

has he tried them out? He said he is not to familiar with them. IDK they are pretty awesome in my book...

Yes. Don't care for the vocals.

I am not familiar with that album, or any album by them for that matter, enough to vote. I've heard their music, but it wasn't my thing.

Damn I dont like either, cant vote on this one.

Think of it like the election DC.

Vote for the lesser of two evils.

yes we need to get this finished so we can move on with more classic albums that everyone hopefully knows...

I'm actually surprised more people aren't familiar with these albums.

tohostudios wrote:

I'm actually surprised more people aren't familiar with these albums.

Me too, perhaps we can start a new poll.

Nightwish - 5
Sirenia - 0

OK, voted for Nightwish only because I am completely unfamiliar with Sirenia.

You'd actually probably prefer Sirenia. They have some growling.

OK, this game is dying a slow painful death outside the main music room. Let's get this thing going again. C'mon people vote! I don't care if you are unfamiliar with the albums, vote anyhow based on what you do know.

Nightwish - 6
Sirenia - 0