Album Elimination Game! Dream Theater vs. Symphony X (VOTE NOW)

I'm going to shy away from the classic band and throw out 2 albums i think rock..

Iced Earth - Something Wicked This Way Comes

vs.

Nevermore - Enemies of Reality

Iced Earth-0
Nevermore-1

Iced Earth-0
Nevermore-2

Iced Earth-1
Nevermore-2

Iced Earth- 1
Nevermore- 3

Love both these CDs. Went with Iced Earth. Could have just as easily have gone with Nevermore.

Iced Earth- 2
Nevermore- 3

Iced Earth - 3
Nevermore - 3

I picked Iced earth cuz i was already a fan of Days of Purgatory and Dark Saga and when i heard SWTWC i was blown away and Iced Earth became one of my favorite bands. When i heard this release from Nevermore they were still pretty new to me so there's the reason behind why i picked IE. Both incredible cd's imo..

Iced Earth - 3
Nevermore - 4

Iced Earth - 4
Nevermore - 4

Iced Earth is the sentimental favorite for me in this battle. If you'd have put "Dead Heart..." up for Nevermore, I would have voted differently.

QuothTheRaven wrote:

Iced Earth - 4
Nevermore - 4

Iced Earth is the sentimental favorite for me in this battle. If you'd have put "Dead Heart..." up for Nevermore, I would have voted differently.

I don't think i could've voted with Dead Heart there those are both high up on my favorite albums ever list...

I'll have to skip this one, never heard either album.

detuned wrote:

I'll have to skip this one, never heard either album.

WOW these are must haves imo...

Iced Earth-5
Nevermore-4

Iced Earth - 6
Nevermore - 4

Iced Earth - 6
Nevermore - 5

Iced Earth 7
Nevermore 5

Iced Earth 8
Nevermore 5

It would have been different had it been this Godless Endeavor

- Robbie

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

Iced Earth 8
Nevermore 6

It would have been different had it been this Godless Endeavor

- Robbie

DID YOU GIVE A POINT TO BOTH BANDS? IT WENT FROM 7 5 TO 8 6

Nah, my post shows a five. I do have moments of retardation though...

Would vote for both if I could, but that kinda defeats the purpose of this thread.

- Robbie

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

Nah, my post shows a five. I do have moments of retardation though...

Would vote for both if I could, but that kinda defeats the purpose of this thread.

- Robbie

nice edit

I didn't edit it! Haha! Maybe someone is looking out for me!

If not we're going crazy.

Somebody vote!



I swear I'm not going crazy! Doesn't it said that I edited if I did!

- Robbie

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

I didn't edit it! Haha! Maybe someone is looking out for me!

If not we're going crazy.

Somebody vote!



I swear I'm not going crazy! Doesn't it said that I edited if I did!

- Robbie

yes it does. i think metalrob is confusing your post with that of metalinmyveins.

Iced Earth - 9

Nevermore - 6

both are really great albums though

mc666 wrote:

theincredibledrechsel wrote:

I didn't edit it! Haha! Maybe someone is looking out for me!

If not we're going crazy.

Somebody vote!



I swear I'm not going crazy! Doesn't it said that I edited if I did!

- Robbie

yes it does. i think metalrob is confusing your post with that of metalinmyveins.

Incredible's post was definitely edited, whether he did it or not. He voted right after me, and I noticed that he had voted for both bands as well. I was going to say something, but MetalRob beat me to the punch. Someone's either not fessing up regarding their brain fart, or we have a sneaky editor on the boards.

The mystery continues.