Spinal Tap Vs. Tenacious D

Which of these 2 bands from the 2 movies This Is Spinal Tap and Tenacious D: The Pick of Destiny do you like better? Post your comments.

Pick all the way. Spinal Tap didnt have a great actor like Jack Black in it.

Tenacious D didn't turn it up to 11

Spinal Tap

Spinal Tap!!!!! It's a classic!!!!! Pick was good, but spinal tap was awesome

Spinal Tap here too.

Spinal Tap were funny. Jack Black is not.

Spinal Tap!! No contest!! Nigel Tufnel could play rings around Jack Black and whatever the other guy's name is with his eyes closed!

Definitely Spinal Tap

i guess im the minority here i thought that movie was

Spinal Tap by miles!

mc666 wrote:

Spinal Tap were funny. Jack Black is not.

Agreed!

That Tenacious D movie is one of the worst movies I've ever seen. Tenacious D is just boring... And not funny.

MetalH wrote:

That Tenacious D movie is one of the worst movies I've ever seen. Tenacious D is just boring... And not funny.

Didn't see the movie because I agree with the second part of this post.

A buddy of mine convinced me to watch the movie. It was beyond horrible.

I was drunk when I watched it. So im gonna have to with Pick all the way. However he never stopped to tune his violin in the middle of a signature 3 instrument solo.

I liked both, but Spinal Tap is a classic though so I'll go with that.

Spinal Tap wasn't a funny movie. I don't see why people think it was.

Never seen the Tenacious D movie.

spectrefate wrote:

Spinal Tap wasn't a funny movie. I don't see why people think it was.

Never seen the Tenacious D movie.

Spinal Tap is hilarious! Tenacious D bore me.

TAP!! TAP!! TAP!!

I've never seen Tenacious D. I never will see Tenacious D. I do not like Jack Black. I never will like Jack Black. Jack Black is a bag of douche disguised as an un-funny, obnoxious, over-bearing human.

spectrefate wrote:

Spinal Tap wasn't a funny movie. I don't see why people think it was.

Are you serious? That movie is laugh out loud funny. Every time I see it, I laugh. I don't see how any long-time rock or metal fan couldn't find the humor in that parody. It's classic! It's full of great one-liners as well.

It's such a fine line between stupid and clever.

:bangyerhead:

ultmetal wrote:

Are you serious? That movie is laugh out loud funny.

As a heart attack. I have watched that movie I think 3 times just to see if there is something I missed, but I just don't find the humor in it. It always seems like there is going to be a payoff that will make me laugh, but it always misses the mark, IMO.

Spinal Tap is funny even while the credits roll.

"He was the patron saint of quality footwear. "

And I'm really picky when it comes to comedies. Usually, what the average person thinks is funny, I find stupid or boring. But to me, Spinal Tap is brilliant; not quite to the Monty Python level, but close.

I do not, for one, think that the problem was that the band was down. I think that the problem may have been...that there was a Stonehenge monument on the stage that was in danger of being crushed by a dwarf. Alright? That tended to understate the hugeness of the object.

I really think you're just making a much too big thing out of it.

Making a big thing out of it would've been a good idea.

Can I raise a practical question at this point? Are we gonna do Stonehenge tomorrow?

No we're not gonna f**king do Stonehenge!!!