Album Elimination Game! Dream Theater vs. Symphony X (VOTE NOW)

biddle wrote:

can't vote on this one. I'm unfamiliar with either band.

That's your fatal mistake right there for this poll boys.

I disagree.

Enough with the Dio vs Iron Maiden polls.

Any metal fan should be familiar with both these bands IMO; even if they hate both. These are both part of the newer breed of metal that still adhere to most of the classic metal elements.

Polls involving albums that have been around for 20+ years get old IMO because we've seen them over and over.

And this is coming from an old fart...

Your right Toho but i'm just saying this poll will drag without a result.

Yeah, probably.

Dream evil-6
Edguy-3

Dammit Sloopbop...

You're prolonging this thing. You should've voted for DE.





j/k...at least you know enough to vote.

tohostudios wrote:

I disagree.

Enough with the Dio vs Iron Maiden polls.

Any metal fan should be familiar with both these bands IMO; even if they hate both. These are both part of the newer breed of metal that still adhere to most of the classic metal elements.

Polls involving albums that have been around for 20+ years get old IMO because we've seen them over and over.

And this is coming from an old fart...

Dream Evil IMO is one of the best metal bands the last 15 years. Awesome traditional metal with tons of power in it. This poll will finish soon we just need more people to come to the fun and games section

Just went to YouTube and listened to about half of each album.

Dream Evil - 7
Edguy - 3

Dream Evil - 8
Edguy - 3

Come on, Come on, Come on.

Dream Evil - 8
Edguy - 4

Dream Evil - 0
Edguy - 4

Dream Evil - 10
Edguy - 4


Do I get a prize?

Let me try:

Sacred Reich - The American Way

vs.

Metal Church - Blessing in Disguise

I have to bow out of this one.

I have heard one Metal Church album and it didn't impress me. I've never heard Sacred Reich.

Push comes to shove I'd vote Sacred Reich. But I'll wait to see if my vote is needed.

Aren't we continuing on from past eliminations?

Deep Purple - Machine Head won it all

since the game was such a hit we are doing the same thing with new albums. We will use 20 albums then drop it in hald to ten and so on. The winner out of all the albums will then face deep Purple.

Sacred reich - 1
Metal Church - 0

American way is a top 5 thrash album

MetalRob331 wrote:

Deep Purple - Machine Head won it all

since the game was such a hit we are doing the same thing with new albums. We will use 20 albums then drop it in hald to ten and so on. The winner out of all the albums will then face deep Purple.

Sacred reich - 1
Metal Church - 0

American way is a top 5 thrash album

And you're not even a thash fan, so that's a shock...

Sacred Reich - 1
Metal Church - 1


I'm just familiar enough with the Sacred Reich album. I've got Surf Nicaragua EP, and if it's anything like that, I have to check it out.

I love both albums but i've been in a more thrash mood lately so...

Sacred reich - 2
Metal Church - 1

Sacred Reich - The American Way -2
Metal Church - Blessing in Disguise -2

Sacred Reich-The American Way-2
Metal Church-Blessing In Disguise-3

Sacred Reich-The American Way-2
Metal Church-Blessing In Disguise-4

This one was tough.

Sacred Reich - 3
Metal Church - 4

Tough one here, but:

Metal Church- 5
Sacred Reich- 3