Opinions on the new Anthrax singer?

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

For those who haven't heard Dan Nelson yet, just following this link to blabbermouth there are a whole bunch of youtube videos there from a recent Anthrax performance, including both Belladonna and Bush songs:
http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode=Article&newsitemID=98685

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

I'm a huge Anthrax fan and have been since they were a local band in the early 80's. Purchased their 'Soldier of Metal' 45 RPM single when it was a new release in 1984. I like the Turbin, Belladonna and Bush years. However, these live clips leave much to be desired. Don't really care for this guy much. Perhaps he will be better on a studio recording, but as it stands, I don't like it much.

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Guest

I don't like him.

I think Scott Ian's irrational man-boy love for Pantera clouded judgement here. The new singer sounds like a Anselmo clone trying to copy John Bush.

I'll be sitting it out until the John Bush reunion happens.

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 2056 Age : 48

Sounds like Phil Anselmo worship. I just don't think this is the right sound for Anthrax. I think I still like him better than Bush though.

Subject: Re: Opinions on the new Anthrax singer? Tue Jun 10, 2008 9:12 am

Those vid clips dont do much for me.Hopefully he'll sound better on an album

Road Warrior Number of posts : 17180 Age : 48

I'll judge after i hear a studio album.

Metal graduate Number of posts : 292 Age : 53

Meh............get Jon back fellas. (mind you Im not a big fan of Jon in Anthrax)

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 1069 Age : 58

Bukkake Tsunami Number of posts : 25557 Age : 53

I wasn't real crazy on what I've heard in those clips. The Belladonna-era stuff is out of his range and the Bush-era was just ok. I'm still interested to hear him on the new album and I hope he has his own style (not just a Bush clone).

Are those clips from his first ever live performance with the band? I'd guess that they are, so I'm willing to cut him some slack and not tear him apart just yet.

Metal graduate Number of posts : 292 Age : 53

Glenn Rogers wrote:: NOT

Ya just cant have an Anthrax thread without someone saying it!

Metal, Movies, Beer Number of posts : 37971 Age : 54

Hmmm... I'm with MetalGuy. Kinda hard to judge this guy based on a couple of not-so-great-quality YouTube clips. But what I did hear was kinda "meh."

_________________
"If you're a false, don't entry, because you'll be burned and died!"

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 1069 Age : 58

OK, he is opening for Iron Maiden. He's on the big stage, but acts like he's still in some club somewhere.
How menny time's do you need to drop the F BOMB...

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 2056 Age : 48

I agree with that. The f-bomb gets real old fast.

Guest

Rexorcist wrote:: I agree with that. The f-bomb gets real old fast.

Smurf yeah it does.

Bukkake Tsunami Number of posts : 25557 Age : 53

Glenn Rogers wrote:: OK, he is opening for Iron Maiden. He's on the big stage, but acts like he's still in some club somewhere.
How menny time's do you need to drop the F BOMB...

That's the kind of stuff you hope will go away with a little experience under his belt, if he lasts that long. Hey, at least he wasn't shadow boxing.

Guest

spectrefate wrote:: I think Scott Ian's irrational man-boy love for Pantera clouded judgement here. The new singer sounds like a Anselmo clone trying to copy John Bush.

That about sums it up. I think he even cusses more than Anselmo. Damn!

Either way, he's not a terrible singer, just very basic. I'll wait until an album drops.

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

i'll wait for the studio output before i make any conclusions. as a whole unit though, Anthrax just isn't that relevant any longer.

_________________
Opinions on the new Anthrax singer? MNxjcKm

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3908 Age : 52

Well being at the show they were playing, I was not impressed live with him at all! Not impressed with Anthrax at all period. I thought he was a pretty generic vocalist.

Guest

He seems ok....

Master Of The Crotch Grab Number of posts : 6841 Age : 50

I dont like him.

Metal master Number of posts : 586 Age : 33

Seems ok i guess

Zooey Addict Number of posts : 17074 Age : 45

I'm just judging him by these clips...HELL NO!!!!!!!!!! This guy is all wrong for Anthrax and is a much worse replacement for Anthrax than Blaze was for Maiden. Hopefully he will sound better in the studio because this is just wrong IMO.

Metal master Number of posts : 673 Age : 53

You can put me in the not impressed crowd as well. A little higher pitched and less gruffy vocalist would've fit Anthrax much better I think.

Road Warrior Number of posts : 17180 Age : 48

He's definately a Anselmo clone trying to sound like John Bush but he actually sounded good on the song Madhouse.

Metal graduate Number of posts : 434 Age : 52

I thought he sounded ok, even if he's trying to sound like Phil a little. Plus, those are live clips, so his voice may have been tired out by then. Let's see how he sounds in studio.

And not being impressed with Anthrax is a valid opinion, but you can't deny Charlie's drumming. The guy can whip nearly anyone else in the genre. Not all, but close.