Good review! I really like this album, and it's probably my favourite of the 5 I have. While I like it better than Unbreakable, that one was really impressive as well.
I would agree about "One Night In December" being the highlight. It also went over great at my stop on the North America tour (Toronto). The only thing I disagree with is "Born With A Broken Heart" being filler. I'm a huge sucker for ballads, and this one is one of my favourites.