UFO or THIN LIZZY

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

Of these two bands, which do you like better?

Both were popular around the same time. Both were equally influential to the metal scene in the early 80's. Both have had some serious contenders for the guitar playing crown. Both have had guitarists who have had offshoot projects that are fantastic.

I've been a fan of both for decades and love them both, but Thin Lizzy has long been my favorite. However, after seeing UFO this past year and gaining a new respect for them, I've become obsessed with them all over again.

Which do you prefer and why?

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

UFO because i'm a big Schenker fan.

_________________
UFO or THIN LIZZY MNxjcKm

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

mc666 wrote:: UFO because i'm a big Schenker fan.

Everybody always says he's a jerk, but when I met him he was very cool.

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 2003 Age : 44

both of them. Lizzy = Ufo. sometimes Ufo is much prefered but than back to Lizzy.
( hmmm ... reminds me of Lizzy Borden )

mini boss Number of posts : 21101 Age : 54

This is like asking which of my twins is a favorite, I love both bands but if I had to choose, I would have to say UFO, simply because I own more of their albums and like mc666 I am huge Michael Schenker fan.
BTW ULT very cool that you have not only seen UFO but met Michael Schenker, never had the privilage to have done either.

Baron Von 40oz. Number of posts : 4386 Age : 34

I like Thin Lizzy more.

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

i'd still much prefer the Scorpions over both of them though.

_________________
UFO or THIN LIZZY MNxjcKm

Metal master Number of posts : 638 Age : 59

UFO but only by a whisker. I have seen Shenker a few times and he is amazing. I regret that I never got the chance to see Thin Lizzy. They came through town a few years back but I didn't get to see them. It would have been cool but it couldn't be the same without Phil Lynott

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

manny wrote:: This is like asking which of my twins is a favorite, I love both bands but if I had to choose, I would have to say UFO, simply because I own more of their albums and like mc666 I am huge Michael Schenker fan.
BTW ULT very cool that you have not only seen UFO but met Michael Schenker, never had the privilage to have done either.

I've met Schenker at a meet and greet. Seen MSG live with Uli Roth at the House of Blues in Hollywood. Also met Uli Roth which was VERY cool.

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Master Of The Crotch Grab Number of posts : 6841 Age : 50

Thin Lizzy. Im a huge Schenker & Way fan as well as UFO in general, but I really enjoy Lynott's compositions and lyrics more that man was a serious poet. Not to mention Thin Lizzy had some pretty good guitar themselves, and Brian Downey is a GREAT drummer

Metal is my Life Number of posts : 26701 Age : 55

DeathCult wrote:: Thin Lizzy. Im a huge Schenker & Way fan as well as UFO in general, but I really enjoy Lynott's compositions and lyrics more that man was a serious poet. Not to mention Thin Lizzy had some pretty good guitar themselves, and Brian Downey is a GREAT drummer

I agree. Thin Lizzy for me!

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

Not a huge fan of either, but I think I'll have to say Lizzy. UFO's great, but they lack the infectious riffs and catchiness Thin Lizzy had.

King Of Kaiju Number of posts : 30892 Age : 64

I go with UFO.

I have sentimental attachments to the band's music.

In college, a bar band called Night Rider was a favorite of my roommate and I. One of their staples was a song called Shoot Shoot. Because the band would sprinkle some originals into their sets, we thought that was one of them. One night while helping the band load their gear into the van we asked them about it. They said it was a UFO song.

Both my roommate and I ran out the next day and bought Strangers In The Night on vinyl. I still flash back to those days when I hear that song.

_________________
"The cat is the most ruthless, most terrifying of animals." - Spock in the "Catspaw" episode of ToS Season 2.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 4272 Age : 65

UFO for me to me just a bit heavier!

Wargod48

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

nevermore wrote:

DeathCult wrote:: Thin Lizzy. Im a huge Schenker & Way fan as well as UFO in general, but I really enjoy Lynott's compositions and lyrics more that man was a serious poet. Not to mention Thin Lizzy had some pretty good guitar themselves, and Brian Downey is a GREAT drummer

I agree. Thin Lizzy for me!

Brian Downey is one of the most underrated drummers ever!

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 5704 Age : 49

THIN LIZZY

Guest

"musically" I love both bands and UFO definitely was a great band. But there's one big difference here...

Phil Lynott

...the guy was a genius songwriter, Thin Lizzy is more memorable for their songs than their riffs or solos. In my opinion of course.

Metal master Number of posts : 820 Age : 59

I will go with UFO, but just by a hair. I believe both bands are/were of immence talent, but I have more pleasent thoughts and feelings with the music of UFO over the last 25+ years.

Dinky Do Number of posts : 4830 Age : 43

I have to go with UFO, Schenker buts them over the top. I like Lizzy but hearing there radio staples as a teenager turned me off from them for a while.

Heavenly Body is my favorite UFO song even though its with Moore

Scurvy Skalliwag Number of posts : 12875 Age : 60

Brian Downey and Andy Parker are two of my favorite drummers. When it is all said and done....UFO

UFO had a lil more consistancy with overall albums and for a few years there, UFO got busy onstage indeed.

Metal master Number of posts : 883 Age : 56

I'm a big Schenker fan so I have to go with UFO. Listening to Black Rose now and I have to say Thin Lizzy is awesome and this is one of their finest.

Metal student Number of posts : 136 Age : 58

Thin Lizzy, easily. UFO has a few songs I do like, and Schenker is undeniably great--but overall UFO's vocals bug me and I don't find most of the songs as catchy or compelling as Thin Lizzy's.

Metal is my Life Number of posts : 40989 Age : 56

Neither. I've never been too impressed with either of them.

King Of Kaiju Number of posts : 30892 Age : 64

Has anyone totalled up the votes to see who's winning?

I think Thin Lizzy is but it's pretty close.

_________________
"The cat is the most ruthless, most terrifying of animals." - Spock in the "Catspaw" episode of ToS Season 2.

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

tohostudios wrote:: Has anyone totalled up the votes to see who's winning?

I think Thin Lizzy is but it's pretty close.

it's UFO.. by one vote. 9 to 8

_________________
UFO or THIN LIZZY MNxjcKm