Would You Buy An Acoustic Metallica Album? I Would!

I wouldn't and the four horsemen soudns funny.

Sure, Metallica has done so much good to my ears, I can forgive one bad album. From what I read in interviews lately, they don`t hide the fact that they are not very proud of St Anger themselves. And they are talking about a more back to their roots sound on the next one, let`s hope so!!!
And acoustic albums can be great!!
I`ll buy it!

Required Fields wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

St. Anger is a name that should never be uttered. It's horrendous.

It is the worst album I have ever heard.

St. Anger isn't that bad actually, it's just not good by Metallica's standards. But Eyesore, they have perhaps not "made a fool" out of fans, but they've certainly disapointed many true fans over the past 15 years, thats not just me, thats fact.
I'd buy an acoustic album by tallica, but I'd buy anything buy Metallica simply because I'm a fan, I just hope that I like many others won't be disapointed by the next studio album, but their live performances from what I've seen have been pretty impressive recently. James' voice is sounding better than it has in years (though the Cookie monster on backing vox is a big mistake!), guitars and drums are still tight and I think Rob's doing a pretty good job. Besides that, they only play about 3 songs from Black Album and thats the most recent stuff, most other songs are pre-Black Album. Can't wait to see them next tour!

Dimedude23 wrote:

Dimedude23 wrote:

Required Fields wrote:

Eyesore wrote:

St. Anger is a name that should never be uttered. It's horrendous.

It is the worst album I have ever heard.

St. Anger isn't that bad actually, it's just not good by Metallica's standards. But Eyesore, they have perhaps not "made a fool" out of fans, but they've certainly disapointed many true fans over the past 15 years, thats not just me, thats fact.
I'd buy an acoustic album by tallica, but I'd buy anything buy Metallica simply because I'm a fan, I just hope that I and many others won't be disapointed by the next studio album, but their live performances from what I've seen have been pretty impressive recently. James' voice is sounding better than it has in years (though the Cookie monster on backing vox is a big mistake!), guitars and drums are still tight and I think Rob's doing a pretty good job. Besides that, they only play about 3 songs from Black Album and thats the most recent stuff, most other songs are pre-Black Album. Can't wait to see them next tour!

yeah same here. metallica could put a turd in a pizza box and i would still buy it (metaphorically speaking of course)

NO.....I don't like acoustic versions of Metal songs.....not my "bag"


I do like Pat Boone's hilarious take on some of this stuff.

as long as is not an acoustic covers album of metal songs then i would buy it but from metallica it would kinda suck

Would you buy an acoustic Metallica album?

I would. Sure, it'd be a bit on the bizarre side (to say the least), but as a fan, I'd probably like it.

Why is TheGooch bumping a ton of Metallica threads?

Without going into a long drawn out conversation, No, I would not.

I would not by an acoustic Metallica album. That band is not getting another penny of my money. Not after St. Anger.

Yeah, why the heck not? I'd wait a while for it to get used and snag it at a cheap price. It would have to have a catchy name too like "Acoustallica"

Required Fields wrote:

I would not by an acoustic Metallica album. That band is not getting another penny of my money. Not after St. Anger.

That makes no sense at all. Bands release bad albums all the time.

Eyesore wrote:

Why is TheGooch bumping a ton of Metallica threads?

If I were to take a wild guess I'd say he's either bored, or drunk, or both.