Fingers controversial opinion thread (no one can agree with

1. Laaz Rockit are one of the most underrated thrash metal bands of all time and is better than Anthrax,SOD and post Rust in Peace megadeth except with the non Dave Ellefson albums.
2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer
3. Reign in Blood is Slayer's worst album if you don't include albums like God hates us All and that punk tribute album they did
4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
5. Wrathchild America's 3D is better than MetallicA except Ride the Lightening and Master of Puppets
6. Led Zeppelin's first 4 albums were overrated and Physical graffiti is their best album
7. Poison only did one good album which was native Tongue the rest were crap
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated with the exception of his work on master of Puppets, his guitar solos on Struggle Within and Through the Never and Ride the Lightening and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
10. Chris Poland's solo albums and Damn the Machine are better than Joe Satriani's and Yngwie Malmsteen's albums and on the same level as Steve vai's. Also Chris Poland is better than Marty Friedman
11. Metal Church's Hanging in the Balance is on the same level as Risk
12. Dream theater is outrageously overrated
13. Word of Mouth is VR's best album with Carl Albert
14. Blaze was more suited on Iron maiden's The X Factor than Bruce was and that album is the best iron maiden album after Seventh Son
15. Dimebag should have been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are overrated
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums except Heaven and Hell
18. Helloween is overrated
19. Krokus is better than Brian Johnson AC/DC with the exception of BIB, For those about to rock, Fly on the Wall and Razors Edge
20. I hear Black and Killbox 13 are Overkill's best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope
21. Artch is better than Metal Church
22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theater
23. Grip Inc is better than Machine Head
24. Prong's Cleansing is better than Reinventing the Steel,half of Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven by Pantera

Quote :

15. Dimebag should of been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated

Odd, you compliment him then tear him down...

Quote :

20. I hear Black and Killbox 13 are Overkill's best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope

Taking Over, Years of Decay and Horrorscope crap all over "I Hear Black", and i like IHB...

Troublezone wrote:

Quote :

15. Dimebag should of been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated

Odd, you compliment him then tear him down...

I love his guitar solos but his riifs I find overrated and I am saying he should of foccused more on guitar solos than riffs

fingers wrote:

Troublezone wrote:

Quote :

15. Dimebag should of been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated

Odd, you compliment him then tear him down...

I love his guitar solos but his riifs I find overrated and I am saying he should of foccused more on guitar solos than riffs

I think he is one of the best and catchiest riff masters of the 90's and he was actually known more for his riffs than solos. Besides, without riffs there is no song.

Troublezone wrote:

fingers wrote:

Troublezone wrote:

Quote :

15. Dimebag should of been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated

Odd, you compliment him then tear him down...

I love his guitar solos but his riifs I find overrated and I am saying he should of foccused more on guitar solos than riffs

I think he is one of the best and catchiest riff masters of the 90's and he was actually known more for his riffs than solos. Besides, without riffs there is no song.

True on without riffs there is no song I just mean more foccused on solos and he should of been a virtouso guitar player instead

fingers wrote:

Troublezone wrote:

fingers wrote:

Troublezone wrote:

Quote :

15. Dimebag should of been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated

Odd, you compliment him then tear him down...

I love his guitar solos but his riifs I find overrated and I am saying he should of foccused more on guitar solos than riffs

I think he is one of the best and catchiest riff masters of the 90's and he was actually known more for his riffs than solos. Besides, without riffs there is no song.

True I just mean more foccused on solos and he should of been a virtouso guitar player instead

To a certain extent he was. Steve Vai even complimented him.

fingers wrote:

1. Laaz Rockit is better than Anthrax,SOD and post Rust in Peace megadeth.
2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer
3. Reign in Blood is Slayer's worst album if you don't include albums like God hates us All and that punk tribute album they did
4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
5. Souls at Zero/Wrathchild America is better than MetallicA except Ride the Lightening and Master of Puppets
6. Led Zeppelin's first 4 albums were overrated and Physical graffiti is their best album
7. Poison only did one good album which was native Tongue the rest were crap
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
10. Chris Poland's solo albums and Damn the Machine are better than Joe Satriani's and Yngwie Malmsteen's albums and on the same level as Steve vai's. Also Chris Poland is better than Marty Friedman
11. Metal Church's Hanging in the Balance is on the same level as Risk
12. Dream theatre is outrageously overrated
13. Word of Mouth is VR's best album with Carl Albert
14. Blaze was more suited on Iron maiden's The X Factor than Bruce was and that album is the best iron maiden album after Seventh Son
15. Dimebag should never of been in a band but only a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums
18. Helloween is overrated
19. Krokus is better than Brian Johnson AC/DC with the exception of BIB, For those about to rock, Fly on the Wall and Razors Edge
20. I hear Black and Killbox 13 are Overkill's best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope
21. Artch is better than Metal Church
22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theatre

i disagree with every one of those statements except #8

Troublezone wrote:

best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope

Taking Over, Years of Decay and Horrorscope crap all over "I Hear Black", and i like IHB...[/quote]

Might change my opinion of Overkill's albums had a look at ultmetal's recent review on their latest album and as soon as I can will get the new album

hopefully better than immortalis

I don't agree with most of those.

But I do agree with:

Quote :

23. Grip Inc is better than Machine Head

Grip Inc is definitely better than Machine Head. Both are good though.

Quote :

24. Prong's Cleansing is better than Reinventing the Steel,half of Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven by Pantera

Prong is better than Pantera period. Except for Pantera's "Power Metal" album (which totally rules by the way).

Quote :

2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer

Probably

Quote :

4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's

Take away Glen Tipton, and I partially agree. I say partially because these players are so different, and not really compareable in style, sound or even era.

Quote :

7. Poison only did one good album which was native Tongue the rest were crap

Again, probably. But I'm not sure I'd call Native Tongue good either....

Quote :

8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin

Apples and oranges.

Quote :

21. Artch is better than Metal Church

That depends on what albums we're talking about.

Quote :

22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theatre

I most def. agree!

[quote="kmorg"]

Quote :

2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer

Probably





2. Cmon first two albums by Vio-lence puts Reign in Blood to shame

Quote :

24. Prong's Cleansing is better than Reinventing the Steel,half of Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven by Pantera

[/quote] is better than Pantera period. Except for Pantera's "Power Metal" album (which totally rules by the way).[/quote]

on the same level. I love Power metal but the musicianship is better on Cleansing

Quote :

21. Artch is better than Metal Church

That depends on what albums we're talking about. [quote]




every album by Artch is better than the albums by Metal Church even though Blessing in Disguise, s/t and Human factor are nearly on the same level as Artch

100% disagree with every single statement, but it is nice to find someone who's opinion I value less then ToB's.

manny wrote:

100% disagree with every single statement, but it is nice to find someone who's opinion I value less then ToB's.

All I can say is, "nobody likes a copycat."

Quote :

4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
18. Helloween is overrated

I agree.

Quote :

11. Metal Church's Hanging in the Balance is on the same level as Risk
12. Dream theatre is outrageously overrated
13. Word of Mouth is VR's best album with Carl Albert
14. Blaze was more suited on Iron maiden's The X Factor than Bruce was and that album is the best iron maiden album after Seventh Son
15. Dimebag should never of been in a band but only a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums
21. Artch is better than Metal Church
22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theatre

You're nuts...and learn how to spell Dream Theater.

fingers wrote:

1. Laaz Rockit is better than Anthrax,SOD and post Rust in Peace megadeth.
2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer
3. Reign in Blood is Slayer's worst album if you don't include albums like God hates us All and that punk tribute album they did
4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
5. Wrathchild America's 3D is better than MetallicA except Ride the Lightening and Master of Puppets
6. Led Zeppelin's first 4 albums were overrated and Physical graffiti is their best album
7. Poison only did one good album which was native Tongue the rest were crap
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated with the exception of his work on master of Puppets, his guitar solos on Struggle Within and Through the Never and Ride the Lightening and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
10. Chris Poland's solo albums and Damn the Machine are better than Joe Satriani's and Yngwie Malmsteen's albums and on the same level as Steve vai's. Also Chris Poland is better than Marty Friedman
11. Metal Church's Hanging in the Balance is on the same level as Risk
12. Dream theater is overrated
13. Word of Mouth is VR's best album with Carl Albert
14. Blaze was more suited on Iron maiden's The X Factor than Bruce was and that album is the best iron maiden album after Seventh Son
15. Dimebag should have been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are overrated
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums except Heaven and Hell
18. Helloween is overrated
19. Krokus is better than Brian Johnson AC/DC with the exception of BIB, For those about to rock, Fly on the Wall and Razors Edge
20. I hear Black and Killbox 13 are Overkill's best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope
21. Artch is better than Metal Church
22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theater
23. Grip Inc is better than Machine Head
24. Prong's Cleansing is better than Reinventing the Steel,half of Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven by Pantera

1. Disagree
2. Disagree
3. Disagree
4. Disagree
5. Who?
6. Nothing about Zeppelin is overrated
7. Agree
8. Disagree
9. Agree
10. Agree on the first part, disagree on the second. Marty is much better IMO.
11. I can't stand Metal Church, but I love Risk
12. Agree
13. Who?
14. Kinda agree (I prefer Virtual XI)
15. Disagree
16. Disagree
17. Disagree
18.Disagree
19. Disagree
20. Disagree
21. Agree
22. Disagree
23. Disagree
24. Disagree

Schbopo wrote:

fingers wrote:

1. Laaz Rockit is better than Anthrax,SOD and post Rust in Peace megadeth.
2. Vio-Lence and Death Angel are better than Slayer
3. Reign in Blood is Slayer's worst album if you don't include albums like God hates us All and that punk tribute album they did
4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
5. Wrathchild America's 3D is better than MetallicA except Ride the Lightening and Master of Puppets
6. Led Zeppelin's first 4 albums were overrated and Physical graffiti is their best album
7. Poison only did one good album which was native Tongue the rest were crap
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated with the exception of his work on master of Puppets, his guitar solos on Struggle Within and Through the Never and Ride the Lightening and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
10. Chris Poland's solo albums and Damn the Machine are better than Joe Satriani's and Yngwie Malmsteen's albums and on the same level as Steve vai's. Also Chris Poland is better than Marty Friedman
11. Metal Church's Hanging in the Balance is on the same level as Risk
12. Dream theater is overrated
13. Word of Mouth is VR's best album with Carl Albert
14. Blaze was more suited on Iron maiden's The X Factor than Bruce was and that album is the best iron maiden album after Seventh Son
15. Dimebag should have been a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are overrated
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums except Heaven and Hell
18. Helloween is overrated
19. Krokus is better than Brian Johnson AC/DC with the exception of BIB, For those about to rock, Fly on the Wall and Razors Edge
20. I hear Black and Killbox 13 are Overkill's best albums and better than the albums of the 80s and horroscope
21. Artch is better than Metal Church
22. Fates Warning have better albums than Dream Theater
23. Grip Inc is better than Machine Head
24. Prong's Cleansing is better than Reinventing the Steel,half of Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven by Pantera

5. Who?
13. Who?

5. http://nolifetilmetal.com/wrathchildamerica.htm
13. Vicious Rumors http://nolifetilmetal.com/viciousrumors.htm

S wrote:

Quote :

4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
18. Helloween is overrated

I agree.

Quote :

11.
15. Dimebag should never of been in a band but only a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums

You're nuts...and learn how to spell Dream Theater.

I have re-edited those 2 I still think Dimebag should have been a virtouso guitar player instead but I was harsh on saying he should never of been in a band but I still think his riffs in Pantera are overrated but NOT totally overrated
I did exaggerate I think that Eternal Idol is Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums with the exception of Heaven and Hell

fingers wrote:

S wrote:

Quote :

4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
18. Helloween is overrated

I agree.

Quote :

11.
15. Dimebag should never of been in a band but only a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums

You're nuts...and learn how to spell Dream Theater.

I have re-edited those 2 I still think Dimebag should have been a virtouso guitar player instead but I was harsh on saying he should never of been in a band but I still think his riffs in Pantera are overrated but NOT totally overrated
I did exaggerate I think that Eternal Idol is Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums with the exception of Heaven and Hell

Don't apologize, stick to your guns. They're YOUR opinions.

Troublezone wrote:

fingers wrote:

S wrote:

Quote :

4. Criss Oliva, Tony iommi and Glen Tipton's guitar playing are better than Jimi hendrix's and Eric Clapton's
8. Judas Priest and Black Sabbath are better than Pink Floyd and led Zeppelin
9. Kirk Hammet is outrageously overrated and is crap if compared to Dave Mustaine
16. s/t by Motley Crue is their best album
18. Helloween is overrated

I agree.

Quote :

11.
15. Dimebag should never of been in a band but only a virtuoso guitar player like Joe Satriani and his riffs in Pantera are totally overrated
17. Eternal Idol is Black Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums

You're nuts...and learn how to spell Dream Theater.

I have re-edited those 2 I still think Dimebag should have been a virtouso guitar player instead but I was harsh on saying he should never of been in a band but I still think his riffs in Pantera are overrated but NOT totally overrated
I did exaggerate I think that Eternal Idol is Sabbath's best album after the first 4 ozzy albums with the exception of Heaven and Hell

Don't apologize, stick to your guns. They're YOUR opinions.

I would of done it anyway and I am not apologizing.
I do love Great Southern Trendkill by Pantera only album by them after Cowboys From Hell that deserves respect and is really good.
I still stick to my opinion on Dream Theater being outrageously overrated they may have talented musicians but their music over the top and a bit fake

.

I agree with 4, 8, 9, 12, 14 and 22.

I agree with numbers 2 and 10. But 20? Listen to Horrorscope again man.

Jesusandmetal23 wrote:

I agree with numbers 2 and 10. But 20? Listen to Horrorscope again man.

Horrorscope rules!