Worst to Best...

I happened to stumble upon a Genesis worst to best album list today on YouTube, while listening to some Y&T. I then decided to check out a couple worst to best for Metallica, but those were sort of predictable. Then I thought about checking out a couple of Megadeth ones. You have a huge sample size album wise and outside of what most consider their top 5, it can get a little dicey. So, I wrote mine down from 15 to 1 and then put the number for the two reviewers next to mine (which you should do first). The first reviewer  had two which were the same as mine (#13 and #11). The second reviewer had three which were the same (#11, #4 and #3). The first reviewer had two albums which were quite a few positions off from mine. The second reviewer had only one album that was more than 3 positions away from mine, but I understand why I would be in the minority with this pick. The second reviewer seems older than the first reviewer. Having said that, I was surprised what his first experience was with Megadeth and I'm sure it was a reason why he ranked a certain album that high. Both videos are no more than 16 minutes, so it's basically a minute per album. It's interesting.





Here's my list in descending order:

15. Super Collider
14. Risk
13. The World Needs A Hero
12. Endgame
11. United Abominations
10. Th1rt3en
09. Dystopia
08. The System Has Failed
07. Cryptic Writings
06. Youthanasia
05. Killing Is My Business...And Business Is Good
04. Countdown To Extinction
03. So Far, So Good... So What!
02. Rust In Peace
01. Peace Sells...But Who's Buying

15. Youthanasia
14. Super Collider
13. Dystopia
12. Th1rt3en
11.  United Abominations
10.  The World Needs A Hero
9.  So Far, So Good... So What!
8.  Killing Is My Business... And Business Is Good!
7.  Cryptic Writings
6.  Endgame
5.  Risk
4.  Peace Sells... But Who’s Buying?
3.  The System Has Failed
2.  Rust In Peace
1.  Countdown To Extinction

I like united abominations. Sleepwalker and Washington is next are both top tracks imho. I would easily place this album in my top 5. Rust in Peace is easily their best album and one of the best metal albums ever released, if not the best.

I will check these videos out, I am always interested in people's opinions on ranking albums. Usually my list will change depending at that point in my life I am at

Something like this, but even the "worst" end is still pretty good. I probably listen to at least one of these albums every week.

The World Needs A Hero
United Abominations
Cryptic Writings
Endgame
Super Collider
Youthanasia
Risk
The System Has Failed
Dystopia
Peace Sells...But Who's Buying
Th1rt3en
Countdown To Extinction
So Far, So Good... So What!
Killing Is My Business...And Business Is Good
Rust In Peace

15 Risk

14 Dystopia

13 The World Needs a Hero

12 Super Collider

11 United Abominations

10 Cryptic Writings

9 Th1rt3en

8 Youthanasia

7 Countdown to Extinction

6 Endgame

5 The System Has Failed

4 Rust in Peace

3 Peace Sells... But Who's Buying?

2 Killing Is My Business... And Business Is Good!

1 So Far, So Good ... So What!

7-15 The rest of them
6 Countdown To Extinction
5 So Far, So Good... So What!
4 Th1rt3en
3 Rust In Peace
2 Peace Sells...But Who's Buying
1 Killing Is My Business...And Business Is Good