Classic rock final four

I know - I could have done this alot better.  But Let's play it out.

Multiple Choice and Vote Cancelling enabled.

Of those 4 choices, Led Zeppelin has been with me the longest. The Stones would be a close 2nd, with Floyd being a late edition to the race. Bad Company's not even in the arena.

If I had to choose, I'd go with Zeppelin. The Stones have always been a rather irritating band to me and the less said about Pink Floyd the better. I'm rather indifferent towards Bad Company.

I went with the Stones, but I am fan of the bands listed

I had to stop and think because I like all these bands.  The conclusion I came to was that while I probably like several individual tracks from the other bands more than I like any single Stones song, overall I like more Stones songs period than any of the other bands.

Stones for me.

Zeppelin. I would pick Bad Company second from this list. I couldn't care less about the Stones and Pink Floyd.

The Rolling Stones - So many songs!

Boris2008 wrote:

The Rolling Stones - So many songs!

Yep!  I put the Jagger/Richards songwriting team right up there with my favorite songwriters.

Led Zeppelin > Rolling Stones >> Bad Company >>>>Pink Floyd

tohostudios wrote:

Boris2008 wrote:

The Rolling Stones - So many songs!

Yep!  I put the Jagger/Richards songwriting team right up there with my favorite songwriters.

Yeah I heard Under My Thumb and Gimme Shelter on the radio today. More than enough to swing it their way 

Zep. But exchange Bad Company with Van Halen or Black Sabbath (I mean there really isn't even any competition there) and that would change.

Van Who? 

Led Zep. The others aren't even close for me.

Great classic rock band and also one of my favourite heavy metal bands.

Led Zeppelin. Floyd second. The Stones and Bad Company following respectfully.

Pink Floyd by a comfortable margin.

I like all these bands but Zep is the one I listen to most out of them.

I picked Zeppelin......could have just as easily been Floyd.

So is it time for the final?

Looks like Zep vs The Stones to me.

tohostudios wrote:

So is it time for the final?

Looks like Zep vs The Stones to me.

Considering the other three bands combined got half as many votes as Led Zep, I can hardly see the final being a cliffhanger!

Led Zeppelin and The Stones for I

Boris2008 wrote:

tohostudios wrote:

So is it time for the final?

Looks like Zep vs The Stones to me.

Considering the other three bands combined got half as many votes as Led Zep, I can hardly see the final being a cliffhanger!

Yeah, it's gonna be a slaughter but let's just play it out.  Personally I'm surprised the Stones got this far. 

We used to do these "tournaments" on another board I was on years ago and it all depends on the brackets.  I bet if Led Zep had been up against someone like Deep Purple in an early round, they wouldn't even be here now.

Led Zep had it all. They were the total Package.

^^^ What he said !

Zeppelin for me. The Stones are a close 2nd. Floyd and then Bad Co. to round it out.

Zep. Love the Stones and Pink Floyd, but I gravitate to Led Zeppelin more often in my listening.