The Replacements

Guest

Can you think of any replacement band members that were better than who they replaced?

Examples:

Hammett for Mustaine?
Dickinson for DiAnno?
Dio for Ozzy?

I personally think all the listed above are improvements for their respective bands.

Others I thought of as improvements were Manni Schmidt for Uwe Luiis (Grave Digger), Craig Goldy for Vivian Campbell (DIO), Zetro for Baloff (Exodus), Billy for Zetro (Testament).

Some disappointments: Morse for Blackmore, Coverdale for Gillan (both Deep Purple), Zack Wylde for Jake E Lee (Ozzy), Whoever Axl has in his band on guitar for Slash, Joe Hasselvander for Gonzo (Raven), Dave Padden for Joe Comeau (Annihilator)...................

You try.

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

Ralf Santolla & Jack Owen replacing the Hoffman brothers in Deicide.
Corpsegrinder replacing Barnes in Cannibal Corpse

_________________
The Replacements MNxjcKm

mini boss Number of posts : 21101 Age : 54

John Bush for Joey Belladonna
I love Paul D'ianno but I think Bruce Dickinson was an improvement
Michael Schenker replacing Mick Bolton in UFO a great improvement
Dave Grohl replacing whoever drummed for Nirvana
Ian Gillan replacing Rod Evans definite improvement

most bands that have replaced vocalist due to death or the member leaving, not so much diappointments but I do prefer the classic line up for example AC/DC or Van Halen, like both line ups but prefer Bon Scott and David Lee Roth .

Guest

Roger Glover replacing Nick Simper in Deep Purple

Guest

Phil Collen 4 Pete Willis
Johnny Edwards 4 Mark Free [Mark had/has a killer voice - III is just my fav KK]
Johnny Rod 4 Blackie Lawless
Gymbo 4 the Cretin [Dayglo Abortions]
and, obviously
Neil Peart 4 John Rutsey

Guest

Quote :: John Bush for Joey Belladonna

Yep.

mini boss Number of posts : 21101 Age : 54

Damn it I can't believe I overlooked the obivious, Neil Peart over John Rutsey !!!

Guest

I'll also take Eric Carr over Peter Criss as well.

mini boss Number of posts : 21101 Age : 54

DenimAndLeather wrote:: I'll also take Eric Carr over Peter Criss as well.

Ditto

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3906 Age : 52

Mikkey Dee replacing Phil Taylor.
Scott Travis replacing Dave Holland
George Fisher replacing Chris Barnes
Dave Padden replacing Joe Comeau
Lee Altus replacing Rick Hunolt
Martin Kearns replacing Andy Whale

Guest

Lurideath wrote:: Scott Travis replacing Dave Holland

Can't agree with that one, all of a sudden Priest getting a thrash drummer never did sit well with me.

Guest

I agree with Shannon there. Holland never seemed to have much to offer, other than basic timekeeping.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3012 Age : 34

mc666 wrote:: Corpsegrinder replacing Barnes in Cannibal Corpse

very true, never could stand Barnes, and I still can't

Guest

The stuff that Holland plays was technically "easy", but simplicity can be a beautiful thing...the guy could create a groove like crazy.

The lost Ramone Number of posts : 6557 Age : 34

Henry Rollins 4 Keith Morris

Keith morris was a savage and I love his style, but Henry Rollins in my opinion gots him beat.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 2682 Age : 37

Slim Dunlap for Bob Stinson in the Replacements.......

Sorry i don't believe that, just being ironic.

Actually Razzle replacing Gyp Casino behind the kit in Hanoi Rocks was a good move, love Razzle's druggy surf beat and Keith Moon like English eccentricity.

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

Steve Howe for Peter Banks in Yes.

» the Replacements
» The Replacements
» Replacements Fans
» If You Like The Replacements or early Goo Goo Dolls...