Nothing wrong with that screamo "genre" as a whole, but the majority do tend to fail at writing good songs. That's all it takes, really. A good song can make a bad vocalist shine. Screamo bands--smurf poo, younger bands in general--just don't get that these days.
It's so easy to create music now, that bands skip right over the fundamentals and go straight into a "working" band. Do bands toil away in garages for years now, before even recording a demo? Hell no. They're together for a month, and they've got a brand-spanking-new CD on the market.
I try not to discriminate genres, but most of this screamo stuff is crap. Most everybody over here either listens to rap or screamo/grindcore junk, and have the "If it's not like this, it's crap" mentality.
I was going to post something similar to what Black halo said, but my computer froze up and I got depressed after typing like 3 paragraphs...here it goes again.
I try not to make fun of the screamo/metalcore/numetal crowd too much because I truly believe they are one and the same as us metallers. It all boils down to all of us likeing heavy edged music. Its just they dont understand whats all out there in the metal realm so they have to make due with the trendy shite. The only difference is that they believe they "know" metal...but they really dont. I say, we be gracious to these people and try and introduce them to real heavy metal as much as possible.
I say, we be gracious to these people and try and introduce them to real heavy metal as much as possible.
I've tried, trust me. I played some Saxon for one of these douches once and he said it 'wasn't heavy enough' and hated the vocals. I left and let him rock out to some Dying Fetus.
I say, we be gracious to these people and try and introduce them to real heavy metal as much as possible.
I've tried, trust me. I played some Saxon for one of these douches once and he said it 'wasn't heavy enough' and hated the vocals. I left and let him rock out to some Dying Fetus.
I say, we be gracious to these people and try and introduce them to real heavy metal as much as possible.
why not just leave them the hell alone & let them enjoy what they want. if they wish to explore further then that's what the internet is for.
I dont know man. I just know it dosnt hurt to try. Nothing to prove nothing to lose right?
EvyMetal Baron Von 40oz.
Number of posts : 4386 Age : 34
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 12:57 am
mc666 wrote:
Lurideath wrote:
Well metalcore is just wannabe tough guy music
doesn't that describe heavy metal as a whole?
NO!! I'm a troo badass!!
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 3:06 am
mc666 wrote:
Lurideath wrote:
Well metalcore is just wannabe tough guy music
doesn't that describe heavy metal as a whole?
If I had to lay money down, I'd be willing to bet that 9 times out of 10, a metalcore fan would kick the shit out of a metal fan.
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 3:08 am
Stender wrote:
mc666 wrote:
Stender wrote:
I say, we be gracious to these people and try and introduce them to real heavy metal as much as possible.
why not just leave them the hell alone & let them enjoy what they want. if they wish to explore further then that's what the internet is for.
I dont know man. I just know it dosnt hurt to try. Nothing to prove nothing to lose right?
It does hurt, though. Let people be who they want to be. There is no right music, no better music. It's all subjective, so just let people like what they like. Metalcore. Penis. Mc666. Whatever.
scottmitchell74 Jada Pinkett Smith's Cabana Boy
Number of posts : 9052 Age : 50
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 3:41 am
Quote :
a metalcore fan would kick the smurf poo out of a metal fan.
:goodluck:
EvyMetal Baron Von 40oz.
Number of posts : 4386 Age : 34
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 4:14 am
I don't know, A lot of metalcore kids I see around look like they don't even know how to throw a punch.
SideShowDisaSter Roo Jockey
Number of posts : 4609 Age : 46
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 11:40 am
Eyesore wrote:
It's so easy to create music now, that bands skip right over the fundamentals and go straight into a "working" band. Do bands toil away in garages for years now, before even recording a demo? Hell no. They're together for a month, and they've got a brand-spanking-new CD on the market.
Post of the year right there folks.
You don't often see that MONSTER of a debut album anymore. You don't hear those songs that bands have probably been working on for years. Nowadays a band doesn't have to flat out blow away a record exec before they have access to the ability to get a CD out. Hell, you don't even see the two or three year wait before a new CD much anymore.
_________________ You're cancer, you can't be the answer, you're killing me
ultmetal Administrator
Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Thu Dec 25, 2008 11:40 am
Eyesore wrote:
It's so easy to create music now, that bands skip right over the fundamentals and go straight into a "working" band. Do bands toil away in garages for years now, before even recording a demo? Hell no. They're together for a month, and they've got a brand-spanking-new CD on the market.
That's true. It takes a while to start gelling as a band.
_________________ ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!
Can't be. I'm as young and Poison are one of my favourites ;P
Also, I find myself agree with Eyesore far too much nowadays, the guy is right again - there just isn't enough development time in modern day bands for songs to be honed and polished. Debut albums used to be one of a band's best because they had spent their 'club days' (for lack of a better phrase) tweaking their songs to their utmost potential before recording. All too often, half-arsed songs now make the cut straight away which is a shame.
It's so easy to create music now, that bands skip right over the fundamentals and go straight into a "working" band. Do bands toil away in garages for years now, before even recording a demo? Hell no. They're together for a month, and they've got a brand-spanking-new CD on the market.
Post of the year right there folks.
You don't often see that MONSTER of a debut album anymore. You don't hear those songs that bands have probably been working on for years. Nowadays a band doesn't have to flat out blow away a record exec before they have access to the ability to get a CD out. Hell, you don't even see the two or three year wait before a new CD much anymore.
Just look at YouTube. You've got these kids that fire up the guitar and then record themselves playing, and it SUCKS! Yet there are people on there that'll tell them they're great. Then there are the haters, so rude that nothing they say sinks in, even though it's probably true. And that turd playing the guitar like a parapalegic with nubs for hands--he's the new breed of musician. And he's definitely got a MySpace page, with the Snocap software on his page so you can download his music. And he's probably got a CD his band is selling for $15 plus $5 S&H, which arrives as a CDR that's had the band's name scrawled on it with an Eraserboard marker, that comes in a plain white CD sleeve, making the worst cassette demos of the 80s look like works of creative genius.
Just look at YouTube. You've got these kids that fire up the guitar and then record themselves playing, and it SUCKS! Yet there are people on there that'll tell them they're great. Then there are the haters, so rude that nothing they say sinks in, even though it's probably true. And that turd playing the guitar like a parapalegic with nubs for hands--he's the new breed of musician. And he's definitely got a MySpace page, with the Snocap software on his page so you can download his music. And he's probably got a CD his band is selling for $15 plus $5 S&H, which arrives as a CDR that's had the band's name scrawled on it with an Eraserboard marker, that comes in a plain white CD sleeve, making the worst cassette demos of the 80s look like works of creative genius.
Pffft!
gotta agree with eyesore on this, spent a few minutes looking up some "metal riffs" and every single one I listened to was that stupid dud dud dum dud dum dud dum dud dum da da da dada type of riff.
and then there this this guy
MetalRob331 Dinky Do
Number of posts : 4830 Age : 43
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Fri Dec 26, 2008 1:20 am
I guess i dont look at it this way at all. Granted that girls playing is really bad, but we all have played like that. I would never make a video of myself if i played that bad. She is trying and thats more then I can say for a lot of the posters on youtube who comment on guitar.
I think there is always a good way to saying something bad. Instead of saying "Gosh you suck" try "Keep practicing".
I have about 15 videos on youtube and none of them have comments....
As for the other 2 riffs, i actually prefer the firsy guys even though its sloppy. The second guy is tuned way too low, and i'm not a big fan of death metal riffs...
Smindas Metal is in my blood
Number of posts : 2546 Age : 35
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Fri Dec 26, 2008 9:08 am
It's not that the first guy is a terrible player per se, but I don't think I've seen such bland and unimaginative riffs in a long time.
_________________
Fat Freddy Metal, Movies, Beer
Number of posts : 37962 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker Fri Dec 26, 2008 9:38 am
Eyesore wrote:
Jeez. Can I get a better example?
Quote :
One hour after picking up the guitar for the 1st time ever... I'm a BEGINNER people! nasty comments are NOT advice...
Good grief. If she were at least somewhat hot, I could let that guitar "performance" slide... but mmm, nope.
By the way, I was never a big death metal guy, don't care for the whole WOOOOAAARRRRRGH vocal style, therefore screamo/metalcore/etc. never did anything for me either.
_________________ "If you're a false, don't entry, because you'll be burned and died!"
Subject: Re: Screamo loving coworker 
Wed Dec 24, 2008 5:17 pm
:goodluck:
