St. Anger vs. Risk

So what turd of an album is worse. I am not a big fan of Metallica so I don't know if I can be fair. I am a big fan of Megadeth but I admit that Risk is not great eiether

i liked St Anger better than Load & Reload. i also liked it better than any Megadeth after RIP.

Both suck big time

I actually really like Risk. The alternative, not so much.

Wow, I honestly can't pick one. Risk is one of the worst albums I have heard from a band that I like. St. Anger sucks just as much, but I can at least appreciate that the band tried to get back to their thrash roots, unlike Megadeth.

I have to vote Risk, sadly.

Risk but i would rather not listen to either..

Gonna go with RISK. There are actually a couple of songs on it that I like.

ST ANGER, however, was totally and completely unlistenable.

Went with Risk - at least the production doesn't sound like it was recorded on a ghetto blaster from the early 80's banging on trash cans!

I'm confused, are we voting on which we think is better, or which is worse?

St. Anger is one of the worst albums ever imo.

Wow, that's like asking "Do you want shot in the foot or the arm?" I guess I have to choose Risk because St. Anger is complete garbage.

Risk is a good album so Risk it is.

St. Anger is HORRIBLE! One of the worst metal albums ever. Risk has some really good tunes, though some are not very good. Risk is a decent album, while St. Anger is putrid.

This would have been very well-received...had it been on a Danzig album. Haha. Always felt this was a total Danzig riff.

Seven And The Ragged Tiger?

Most of the songs from Risk slowly crept into the back of my mind so they would just start randomly playing. Suddenly I'd find myself humming the melodies and feel an urge to listen to Risk.

I like Frantic, but St. Anger is far too hard to listen to from start to end without getting bored... But I find that with most Metallica albums.

I went with Risk.

Voted for Risk. I can deal with Risk. St. Anger gets on my nerves.

Risk

St. Anger

Megadeth after Youthanasia was un-listenable.

I downloaded St. Anger (wouldn't pay for it) just to give it a fair shake. I played the first few seconds of each song and couldn't take it so I deleted it. I ended up downloading it again, but I haven't listened to it at all. Risk is pretty bad, but there are a few decent songs.

Even though I don't really like either album I went with Risk. It's a tad bit better than St. Anger.

I tried to remove myself from favoring Megadeth ( one of my favorite bands), so I went with how much I hate the snare bong bong bong bong ever present in St. Anger. However Risk far from a favorite of mine. I like a song here or there on the album but not much else to say for that album

Eyesore wrote:

This would have been very well-received...had it been on a Danzig album. Haha. Always felt this was a total Danzig riff.

This song is better than anything on St. Anger, so Risk gets my vote!!!

Risk.

Love Prince of Darkness. Cool lyrics.

You're meant to vote for your least favourite album of the two. The question was: "so what turd of an album is worse?"