VH1's Top 100 Greatest Hard Rock Songs Results!

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3325 Age : 53

56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

metalinmyveins wrote:: 56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

It's still a catchy little song though. Very Happy

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3325 Age : 53

Schbopo wrote:

metalinmyveins wrote:: 56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

It's still a catchy little song though. Very Happy

I absolutely detest the song. When Janie talks about that song on the VH1 program "History of Metal"; he was practically in tears. He said that his whole legacy will be that of the Cherry Pie guy. I give the guy credit for being so candid regarding the abomination that is that song.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3012 Age : 35

Schbopo wrote:

metalinmyveins wrote:: 56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

It's still a catchy little song though. Very Happy

I love this song.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3282 Age : 43

Was this another one of their 5-part Top 100 series or did they only do a show for the top 20?

Sounds decent, I'll catch it on one of the millions reruns VH1 likes to do...

Administrator Number of posts : 863 Age : 54

metalinmyveins wrote:: 56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

Actually, Jani has backed off from that statement. He says what he despised was the fact that the band became Cherry Pie for all intents and purposes. He said the video, the fact that it was the lead single, they changed the album name, had pie eating contests at concerts, etc., THOSE are the things that made him mad about it. He said he couldn't believe so much attention was given to a song he wrote in about 10 minutes.

Arttie

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3325 Age : 53

arttieTHE1manparty wrote:

metalinmyveins wrote:: 56. Cherry Pie-Warrant

It's absolutely laughable when you see this song on the list, especially when Janie Lane has stated that he could shoot himself in the head for writing this song. The song basically has ruined his life. It just goes to show you that those who voted on this are absolutely clueless!!!

Actually, Jani has backed off from that statement. He says what he despised was the fact that the band became Cherry Pie for all intents and purposes. He said the video, the fact that it was the lead single, they changed the album name, had pie eating contests at concerts, etc., THOSE are the things that made him mad about it. He said he couldn't believe so much attention was given to a song he wrote in about 10 minutes.

Arttie

Has he backed off that statement? I also saw him talk about how much he hated that song on one of the Celebrity Fit Clubs he was on as well. He seems pretty adamant regarding his hatred of this song, and everything that it brought to his career.

Watch the last 15 seconds of this clip, and tell me that he has backed off this statement. A person doesn't have tears well up in their eyes, and say what he said, if he actually didn't mean it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVt2z0q9F2c&feature=related

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

I don't think he hates the song itself, just what came with it.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3325 Age : 53

Schbopo wrote:: I don't think he hates the song itself, just what came with it.

Which in essence is the same thing. He never wanted to write the song in the first place. He said the record was done. Not to mention the fact that when an artist tells the general public that they wrote a song in a matter of minutes, there's not much to speculate regarding the song and its quality.

Guest

Who cares? "Cherry Pie" is easily in the top 100 greatest hard rock song off all-time. Cheesy as hell, sure, but it's a damn catchy song.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3012 Age : 35

Edit: nevermind

Guest

sam wrote:: Edit: nevermind

Chicken.

Metal, Movies, Beer Number of posts : 37971 Age : 54

Typical VH1 crap. Some good songs, a lot of bad songs, and lots of not-subtle-at-all promos for the Rock Band video game and Bret Michaels' upcoming "Rock of Love Bus" show.

That said, I still watched the last couple of hours of this thing last night (couldn't sleep and there was nothing better on TV at the time)... couldn't help myself, these countdown shows are like video crack!!

_________________
"If you're a false, don't entry, because you'll be burned and died!"

Administrator Number of posts : 863 Age : 54

Well, if you watch this actual countdown, he even talks about it and says pretty much exactly what I said above.

Arttie

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

Fat Freddy wrote:: That said, I still watched the last couple of hours of this thing last night (couldn't sleep and there was nothing better on TV at the time)... couldn't help myself, these countdown shows are like video crack!!

No kidding. " Best songs of the 80s", "best songs of the 90s", " best hard rock artists", "best kid stars", "best teen stars", I've seen em all more times I can count....just because there was nothing else on.
Mad

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3325 Age : 53

arttieTHE1manparty wrote:: Well, if you watch this actual countdown, he even talks about it and says pretty much exactly what I said above.

Arttie

I agree. Everything you stated was verbatim with what Janie Lane stated, EXCEPT the supposed softer stance that Janie feels regarding the song Cherry Pie. I don't follow his every word, but when I have heard Janie speak (regarding this song); he regards the writing of this song as nothing more than a total nightmare.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3012 Age : 35

Eyesore wrote:

sam wrote:: Edit: nevermind

Chicken.

ehh...I did post about how much bret is a smurfette, bad host, etc... before realizing this had all been covered before.

Ate his vegetables Number of posts : 4958 Age : 34

sam wrote:: ehh...I did post about how much bret is a smurfette, bad host, etc... before realizing this had all been covered before.

He's only on screen for about 3 seconds at a time, how can he be a bad host?

Metal novice Number of posts : 36 Age : 44

Meh, just like any other list. but Guns n roses #1?!?! now THAT is pushing it. But its just a sily list like every other list.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 3012 Age : 35

Schbopo wrote:: He's only on screen for about 3 seconds at a time, how can he be a bad host?

because he's a tool Very Happy

mini boss Number of posts : 21101 Age : 54

I find it entertaining but I do not take these lists shows seriously, most of the people that vote for these songs are causal metal/hard rock fans at best. If VH1 or VH1 classics have a list show regarding metal I always watch it, even if the results are somewhat predictable.

Metal is in my blood Number of posts : 4214 Age : 50

Then when lists like this come out the hardcore music fans need to vote just my opinion

Guest

Quote :: 99. We're an American Band-Grand Funk Railroad

99th my ass.

Metal novice Number of posts : 2 Age : 50

Mattallica667 wrote:: VH1's "Top 100 Greatest Hard Rock Songs" Final 20 songs were released earlier tonight. The event was hosted by Bret Michaels, and, for the record, didn't contain anything TOO metal (Slayer, Pantera, etc.). Here is the complete list (and yes, i did take the time to write it all down. Some of the songs are out of place, and once again, this is VH1's list (as voted by the people) not mine. Though I would very much like for at lest ONE person to make there own list in response so we can all compare.

Here is the list:

100. I Can't Drive 55 -Sammy Hagar
99. We're an American Band-Grand Funk Railroad
98. Lit Up-Buckcherry
97. Frankenstein-Edgar Winter
96. Carry on My Wayward Son-Kansas
95. Higher-Creed
94. I Believe In a Thing Called Loved-The Darkness
93. Turn Up the Radio-Autograph
92. Don't Tell Me You Love Me-Night Ranger
91. Bullet With Butterfly Wings-Smashing Pumpkins
90. Aqualung-Jethro Tull
89. Party Hard-Andrew W.K.
88. Would?-Alice In Chains
87. Seventeen-Winger
86. The Beautiful People-Marilyn Manson
85. Slither-Velvet Revolver
84. I Wanna Be Somebody-W.A.S.P.
83. Bring Me Back to Life-Evanescence
82. Since You've Been Gone-Rainbow
81. Heaven and Hell-Black Sabbath
80. Any Way You Want It-Journey
79. Rebel Yell-Billy Idol
78. Feel Like Makin' Love-Bad Company
77. Black Hole Sun-Soundgarden
76. Kiss Me Deadly-Lita Ford
75. Seven Nation Army-White Stripes
74. Love Removal Machine-The Cult
73. Jailbreak-Thin Lizzy
72. Heartbreaker-Pat Benatar
71. Mountain Song-Jane's Addiction
70. Hot Blooded-Foreigner
69. Cult of Personality-Living Colour
68. More Human Than Human-White Zombie
67. Tush-ZZ Top
66. The Final Countdown-Europe
65. Kick Out the Jams-MC5
64. Liar-Rollin's Band
63. Eye of the Tiger-Survivor
62. Breaking the Chains-Dokken
61. Round and Round-RATT
60. 18 and Life-Skid Row
59. The Stroke-Billy Squier
58. Interstate Love Song-Stone Temple Pilots
57. You Really Got Me-The Kinks
56. Cherry Pie-Warrant
55. Don't Fear the Reaper-Blue Oyster Cult
54. Epic-Faith No More
53. Born to Be Wild-Steppenwolf
52. Cherry Bomb-The Runaways
51. Peace Sells-Megadeth
50. Give It Away-Red hot Chili Peppers
49. Search and Destroy-Iggy Pop and the Stooges
48. Freak on a Leash-\"thebandthatshallneverbementionedagain\"
47. Bawidabata-Kid Rock
46. Madhouse-Anthrax
45. Slow Ride-Foghat
44. Sunshine of Your Love-Cream
43. Holy Diver-Dio
42. Should I Stay or Should I Go-The Clash
41. Cum on Feel the Noize-Quiet Riot
40. Talk Dirty to Me-Poison
39. More Than a Feeling-Boston
38. Stone Cold Crazy-Queen
37. My Generation-The Who
36. Hot for Teacher-Van Halen
35. School's Out-Alice Cooper
34. Barracuda-Heart
33. Basket Case-Green Day
32. Cat Scratch Fever-Ted Nugent
31. Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap-AC/DC
30. Even Flow-Pearl Jam
29. Bad Reputation-Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
28. Everlong-Foo Fighters
27. Still of the Night-Whitesnake
26. Freebird-Lynyrd Skynyrd
25. Blitzkrieg Bob-Ramones
24. In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida-Iron Butterfly
23. Crazy Train-Ozzy Osbourne
22. Hey Joe-Jimi Hendrix Experience
21. Kashmir-Led Zeppelin
20. You Give Love a Bad Name-Bon Jovi
19. Tom Sawyer-Rush
18. Rock You Like a Hurricane-Scorpions
17. I Wanna Rock-Twisted Sister
16. Rock and Roll All Nite-KISS
15. Dr. Feelgood-Motley Crue
14. Run to the Hills-Iron Maiden
13. Photograph-Def Leppard
12. Breaking the Law-Judas Priest
11. Smoke on the Water-Deep Purple
10. Ace of Spades-Motorhead
9. Runnin' with the Devil-Van Halen
8. Walk this Way-Aerosmith
7. Smells Like Teen Spirit-Nirvana
6. Won't Get Fooled Again-The Who
5. Enter Sandman-Metallica
4. Paranoid-Black Sabbath
3. Whole Lotta Love-Led Zeppelin
2. Back In Black-AC/DC
1. Welcome to the Jungle-Guns N' Roses

Metal novice Number of posts : 2 Age : 50

sam wrote:

Schbopo wrote:: He's only on screen for about 3 seconds at a time, how can he be a bad host?

because he's a tool Very Happy

who wears their own T-Shirt?

» 100 Greatest Hard Rock Songs-Schbopo style
» VH1 new special 100 greatest hard rock songs special
» One of the greatest songs ever!
» Favorite "New" songs from Greatest Hits albums
» Rolling Stones 500 Greatest songs of all time