Cirith Ungol vs Manilla Road

Metal master Number of posts : 757 Age : 30

My friend and I were having this debate. Figured why not ask all of you.

Personally, I gotta go with Cirith Ungol. Yes, Manilla Road have Crystal Logic and some good albums but man King of the Dead and Frost and Fire are truly classics!

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 7641 Age : 56

Cirith Ungol for me.

Scurvy Skalliwag Number of posts : 12875 Age : 60

What witchbrother said....

_________________
Cirith Ungol vs Manilla Road Th?id=OIP.Mf8_L3e01kyREFChW4XK_gEsDG&w=299&h=198&c=7&qlt=90&o=4&dpr=1.25&pid=1

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 6403 Age : 44

I'm not really a fan of either vocalist.

Metal master Number of posts : 896 Age : 50

I love Cirith Ungol, but I don't think I've heard anything by Manilla Road. It's not fair for me to vote until I check them out, but they'd have to blow my mind to beat out Cirith Ungol.

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 9948 Age : 49

Went for cirith ungol by default. Not familiar with manila and i only know a couple of cirith songs.

I definitely need to investigate those two.

Metal is my Life Number of posts : 26701 Age : 55

I have to go with Cirith Ungol too.

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 6719 Age : 53

Cirith Ungol

_________________
FINAL SIGN

Metal is my Life Number of posts : 28676 Age : 39

Manilla Road has my vote.

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 1064 Age : 31

Mark Shelton's voice is unbearable so Cirith Ungol

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 5094 Age : 27

I feel bad for Manilla Road, cos they slay too, but Cirith Ungol is f*cking classic kult metal in my eyes. One of the best underground bands from any metal scene/sub-genre, even. So Ungol gets my vote.

Heart of Metal Number of posts : 1064 Age : 31

On a related note, this band popped up in my youtube. Pretty good, definitely worth listening if you like this kind of epic metal. All the charm of 80s recording quality included.

Metal master Number of posts : 896 Age : 50

I gave Manilla Road a chance and listened to their first two albums. Not diggin' 'em, so Cirith Ungol is the easy choice.

Administrator Number of posts : 19452 Age : 57

Live 'em both. Manilla Road definitely has a larger and more varied catalog but I've been a Frost fan since the 80's so I went with them.

_________________
ULTIMATUM - TOO METAL FOR WIKIPEDIA!

Metal master Number of posts : 757 Age : 30

BearOnUnicycle wrote:: On a related note, this band popped up in my youtube. Pretty good, definitely worth listening if you like this kind of epic metal. All the charm of 80s recording quality included.

AMAZING!

Metal master Number of posts : 757 Age : 30

80s Metal Lady wrote:: I gave Manilla Road a chance and listened to their first two albums. Not diggin' 'em, so Cirith Ungol is the easy choice.

Check out Crystal Logic.

Master Sailboat Number of posts : 9301 Age : 45

Manilla Road all the way. Open the Gates!!!!!!

_________________
Cirith Ungol vs Manilla Road MNxjcKm

Metal master Number of posts : 896 Age : 50

choosemetal wrote:

80s Metal Lady wrote:: I gave Manilla Road a chance and listened to their first two albums. Not diggin' 'em, so Cirith Ungol is the easy choice.

Check out Crystal Logic.

I'm checking it out now. I will say, I REALLY like the title track. Going to add that to my mp3 player.

Metal novice Number of posts : 24 Age : 51

Long time fan of both, but I would have to say Cirith Ungol.

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 7831 Age : 44

Cirith Ungol. I have tried numerous times to like Manilla Road but just can’t.

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 9948 Age : 49

Finally ordered 3 cirith ungol albums on amazon. Hope to receive them soon.

Metal novice Number of posts : 24 Age : 51

Gilbert wrote:: Finally ordered 3 cirith ungol albums on amazon. Hope to receive them soon.

Which ones?

Metal is Forever Number of posts : 9948 Age : 49

zlogdan wrote:

Gilbert wrote:: Finally ordered 3 cirith ungol albums on amazon. Hope to receive them soon.

Which ones?

Frost and Fire, one foot in hell and paradise lost.

I will eventually get their second one, once i find it for a cheaper price.

I must say that i loved the samples i heard on paradise lost headbanger

Metal novice Number of posts : 24 Age : 51

Gilbert wrote:

zlogdan wrote:

Gilbert wrote:: Finally ordered 3 cirith ungol albums on amazon. Hope to receive them soon.

Which ones?

Frost and Fire, one foot in hell and paradise lost.

I will eventually get their second one, once i find it for a cheaper price.

I must say that i loved the samples i heard on paradise lost headbanger

Paradise lost is a great album, but Jerry Fogle, the incredible guitar player in the first 3 albums, is not playing with them. A very good album anyway. I like the other three better, but that is just my opinion Smile

Back in the 80s, the first two were released here in Brazil as LPs but their label switched the covers, so KoTD had FaF cover and vice versa. As a teen back then I could only find and afford King OF The Dead which I overplayed. It is a classic and unique album which I hope you find an affordable copy very soon! headbanger

Metal novice Number of posts : 24 Age : 51

It was a complete tragedy what has happened to Mark Shelton, RIP. I knew of his passing in the time it had happened but I was going through some depression/anxiety times back then when it had happened so I was not listening to any music. I have recovered somehow and now I am listening to the albums.
It was a great surprise to see that Google Play music now sells The Deluge and Out Of The AByss in digital format now so I acquired both. The latter was an album I have never heard before so imagine the impact it had on me, an awesome metal classic.